Have you ever watched the extended editions of "The Lord of the Rings" in one sitting?

Why people ask this

This question works because the yes-or-no split always surprises the room — someone answers in a way nobody expected, and the conversation starts from there. Niche obsessions are usually masked in public; this question is one of the few permission slips to admit how deep the rabbit hole actually goes. The yes-or-no format is what makes it work — nobody has to volunteer a story, but once someone says yes the room always wants to hear it. That is why this question comes up again even in groups that have played before: the answer changes, the story changes, and the same question lands differently every time someone new is in the room.

What do players say?

17%

of players said Yes
12 responses

Based on 12 answers so far, 17% of players say yes — making this one of the rarer things players admit to.

Discussion starters

→ Who in the group is most likely to have watched the extended editions of "The Lord of the Rings" in one sitting?
→ What's the full story — and who in the group is most surprised by your answer?
→ What fandom do you keep quiet about in public?
→ What is the most you have spent on something nobody else in your life understands?
→ What hobby has earned you the most "are you okay?" looks?

Ever challenged yourself to sit through all of the extended editions of "The Lord of the Rings" trilogy in one epic marathon? This question uncovers your commitment to fantasy worlds and how much you're willing to immerse yourself in a cinematic journey. Whether you're a seasoned Tolkien fan or someone who just loves a good movie marathon, this question sparks fun conversations about dedication, favorite scenes, and movie nights that go beyond the ordinary.

What This Question Really Asks

This question digs into your movie-watching habits and your level of dedication to beloved film series. It’s about more than just watching movies; it’s about the experience, patience, and passion for fan-favorite extended editions or special director's cuts. By asking this, you might discover how people prioritize their movie time and their willingness to indulge in lengthy stories. It also provides insight into their love for film and television marathons, their patience levels, and their geeky side.

Whether they find the movies worth sitting through in one go.
How much they love the Peter Jackson trilogy.
Their dedication to completing ambitious viewing challenges.
If they prefer intense, lengthy binge sessions over shorter movie nights.
Their knowledge and passion for fantasy films.

How to Use This Question

Setting	Tone	Best for	Tip
Friends game night	Playful, relaxed	Breaking the ice with fellow Tolkien fans	Encourage everyone to share their favorite scene during the marathon.
First date	Warm, engaging	Getting to know each other's tastes	Ask if they’ve ever attempted this challenge to gauge their dedication.
Team meeting	Informal, fun	Building camaraderie over shared interests	Use it as a way to find out about colleagues' geeky hobbies or movie preferences.
Family dinner	Casual, hearty	Sharing a beloved hobby with loved ones	Discuss favorite movie editions and experiences.
Party	Festive, lively	Creating memorable moments	Turn it into a trivia game about "The Lord of the Rings".

When You Say "Yes"

You’re a hardcore nerd who loves epic fantasy stories.
You enjoy marathons and challenging your endurance.
You’ve watched the extended editions more than once and are proud of it.
You appreciate the depth and details added in the extended versions, like extra scenes or background info.
You're proud to have completed this challenge or aspire to do it someday.