Play
Categories
Tools
Questions
Blog
Why people ask this
This question travels because secrets are heavy and the urge to put one down — even just into a game — is stronger than most people admit. On have.you, this question is part of a category played by people across every kind of setting — parties, road trips, dinners, late-night calls — which is why the same question reads differently in every group. The interesting part is rarely the answer itself; it is the follow-up, the story behind the yes, or the surprised reaction when somebody answers the opposite way. That is what keeps Have You Ever questions in rotation long after most party games get retired.
What do players say?
5 responses
Discussion starters
- → What is the longest you have kept a secret?
- → What is one lie you tell to keep the peace?
- → What is something you have done that nobody in this room knows?
- → What is the worst thing you have ever lied about on a CV?
- → What is a small lie you tell daily?
Ever wondered about those hidden moments that shape your friendships? This question helps peel back the layers of trust and reveals how candid you really are with your best friend. Curious? Explore more classic questions and see what they reveal about your relationships.
What This Question Really Asks
This question probes into your honesty and trustworthiness in close relationships. It examines whether you have secrets that could impact your friendship and how comfortable you are sharing everything. It’s a good way to understand deeper feelings about loyalty and honesty, and it can lead to revealing stories that bring you closer.
- Have you ever withheld important information from your best friend?
- Do you keep secrets because you're afraid of hurting your friend or damaging trust?
- Are there times when you feel your secret is justified, even if it’s kept from them?
- Thinking about this question can bring up situations worth discussing on deeper topics.
- It’s also a chance to reflect on your honesty in other close relationships.
How to Use This Question
| Setting | Tone | Best for | Tip |
|---|---|---|---|
| Friends game night | Playful and lighthearted | Getting to know each other better | Encourage honesty with humor and warmth. Check out group decider to pick the perfect moment. |
| First date | Honest and sincere | Building trust early on | Use this question to create meaningful conversations, but be mindful of comfort levels. |
| Team meeting | Professional yet personal | Fostering openness | Frame it as sharing personal stories to strengthen team bonds rather than prying. |
| Family dinner | Warm and intimate | Deepening family bonds | Share your own secrets first to encourage openness. |
| Party | Casual and fun | Breaking the ice | Use lighthearted follow-ups to keep the mood upbeat; see funny and embarrassing questions. |
When You Say "Yes"
- You value honesty and believe secrets can sometimes harm trust.
- You feel a genuine closeness that makes sharing secrets natural.
- You have shared personal things, knowing it deepens your friendship.
- You know that secrets, once kept, can weigh heavily or cause guilt.
- You might realize there’s a secret you’re not ready to share, leading to honest conversations.
When You Say "No"
Not sharing secrets can be for various reasons. Maybe you want to protect your friend or avoid unnecessary drama. Some prefer to keep personal matters private and see friendships as being based on trust without full disclosure.
- You believe some secrets are best left untold to preserve harmony.
- You think trust doesn’t necessarily mean sharing everything.
- You might have unresolved issues that make sharing difficult.
Best Follow-Up Questions
- How do you feel when you keep a secret from someone you trust?
- Have you ever regretted revealing a secret?
- What do you think makes a friendship strong enough to handle secrets?
- Have you ever had to choose between honesty and loyalty?
- Would you ever forgive a friend who kept a secret from you?
For more ideas on sparking honest conversations, check out our conversation starters category.
Ready to learn more about your relationships? Start playing with this question or invite friends to join in the multiplayer game to make it even more fun and revealing!